American Legion
Mitchell Post #281
About Us
The Shelter Island American Legion Mitchell Post #281 was founded on February 22, 1922. Our post is part of the American Legion organization, which was chartered and incorporated by Congress in 1919 as a patriotic veterans organization devoted to mutual helpfulness. We are committed to supporting active-duty members of the U.S. Armed Forces, veterans and their families in need, and to serve the Shelter Island community in any capacity we can.
We have an excellent venue available to rent out for events. The venue includes a full service kitchen, dining area, fully equipped bar, as well as a two lane bowling alley. Visit our "Rentals" page for more information on how to have your next event at Post #281.
The Shelter Island American Legion is a 501(c)19 tax exempt charitable organization. All donations to us are tax deductible (donation receipt available upon request).
Donations can by made by visiting our "Donations" page or via check made out to "American Legion Mitchell Post #281"
You will find our contact information on our "Contact Us" section.
All donations are appreciated and help us carry out our mission. Thank you!
Post #281 Monthly Meeting
Third Monday of the Month
7-8 PM
Eligibility
Recent Congressional legislation has expanded the war time eligibility period for membership in The American Legion.
The LEGION Act declares that the United States has been in a state of war since Dec. 7, 1941 so anyone who has served federal active duty in the U.S. Armed Forces since then is eligible for membership, so long as they're still serving honorably or were honorably discharged. Visit our "Membership" page for more information on how to join.
Not a veteran? That's OK! Click to see how you can become a Booster Member today!
50K for Veterans Day
The American Legion needs YOUR help!
For over 102 years the American Legion Mitchell Post has provided a safe haven and gathering place to Shelter Island veterans and residents alike. From winter bowling leagues, to community events, Mitchell Post #281 has been a centerpiece of Shelter Island.
Years of use and service has left the legion in desperate need of repairs. We are raising funds for a significant restoration of the American Legion so that it may continue to serve our local veterans, military members, and community. Funds will specifically be used for the following:
V
-
New kitchen appliances - $15,000
-
Renovate women’s restroom - $10,000
-
Replace 1962 bowling alley with two modern lanes - $200,000
-
Repair entrance stairway - $10,000
-
Remodel flooring and bar area – $15,000
ONLY 1,000 TICKETS
WILL BE SOLD
Drawing on Nov 11th, 2025
*The Drawing will take place at the Veterans Day Dinner at Mitchell Post #281
1 Bateman Rd, Shelter Island, NY
Tuesday, November 11, 2025 4:30 PM
Ticket Questions please call 631-749-1180
2025 Ticket Sellers
-
Mitchell Post #281, 1 Bateman Rd
-
Stars Cafe, 17 Grand Ave
-
Shelter Island Ace Hardware, 4 Grand Ave
-
Shelter Island Pharmacy, 19 Grand Ave
-
South Ferry Office, 135 S. Ferry Rd
-
Lenz Winery, 38355 Main Rd, Peconic
2024 Veteran of the Year
-Suffolk County-
What We Do
Our initiatives focus on improving the lives of active duty service members, veterans and their families by providing them a safe haven to build comradery, and assisting them to obtain essential services, support, and resources. From healthcare initiatives to community outreach programs, we strive to make a positive impact on the lives of those who have served.
Veteran Health
Ensuring Well-Being
We focus on veterans' health by advocating for mental health support, helping them navigate Veteran Affairs benefits, and providing access to resources that enhance overall well-being. Our aim is to guarantee that veterans receive the care and support necessary for them to lead healthy and fulfilling lives.
Community Outreach
Building Connections
Through community outreach programs, we aim to strengthen the bond between veterans and the local community. These initiatives create a sense of belonging, support, and understanding for veterans transitioning to civilian life.
Education
Empowering Through Knowledge
We are committed to the pursuit of higher education and service within the community. Each year we provide educational opportunities and scholarships to our local youth. We believe that our military veterans are living textbooks of American history. Their accounts of experiences while in uniform are preserved and shared with the local community through our various events.
Calendar of Events
Announcements
-
03/18/25- It is with a heavy heart we announce the passing of Army veteran Lawrence J. Winston. There will be a private celebration of Larry's life on Shelter Island this summer. Our thoughts are with Larry and his family.
-
02/26/25 - It is with a heavy heart we announce the passing of Herbert Sherman Jr, Korean War Veteran, at the age of 89. Funeral services will be held Saturday, March 8th at 11 a.m. at Shelter Island Presbyterian Church. Interment with U.S. Air Force Honors will follow at Emily French Cemetery. Our thoughts are with Herb and his family.
Veteran Resources
-
Veterans Crisis Line - 1-800-273-8255 (a 24/7, confidential resource for veterans, their families, and friends in crisis.)
-
National Call Center for Homeless Veterans - 877-424-3838 (a resource for veterans who are homeless or at risk)
-
Riverhead Veterans Affairs Clinic - 631-754-7978, 300 Center Drive, Riverhead, NY 11901
-
Northport Veterans Affairs Medical Center - 631-261-4400, 79 Middleville Rd, Northport, NY 11768